What Hollandse Nieuwe Actually Is
Herring in the Netherlands is salted, not cooked. The fish is gutted, lightly cured in brine and frozen briefly by law before sale, which is why the herring you buy on a Noord-Holland street stall is safe to eat without heat. The season labelled Hollandse Nieuwe runs from roughly early June, when the first barrels are auctioned in Scheveningen, until the end of September; outside those months stalls sell the previous year's catch, which is firmer and saltier. Expect a soft, rich texture closer to sashimi than to the pickled herring sold in jars further north in Europe.
The classic serve is a whole fish with onion and a slice of sour pickle, and you eat it by holding it by the tail and lowering it into your mouth in one or two bites. If that feels ambitious, ask for a broodje haring, a soft white roll with the fish filleted on top. Stalls will also sell you haring with onions chopped small and mixed through, which softens the hit for a first attempt. Prices at street stalls in Noord-Holland generally sit in the low single-figure euro range for a broodje, and a whole fish is usually a little less.
Where to Eat It in Noord-Holland
Amsterdam is where most visitors meet herring, and the stalls are clustered in the centre. The stands around the Albert Cuypmarkt in De Pijp and on the Spui are long-established and busy, and you can pair a fish with a walk along the canals. Haarlem, twenty minutes by train from Amsterdam Centraal, has a market on the Grote Markt on Saturdays where a herring stall sits among the cheese and flower sellers. Alkmaar's Waagplein, famous for its Friday cheese market between April and September, has seafood stands nearby. All three towns are compact enough to reach a stall on foot from the station in under fifteen minutes.
For something closer to the source, head west to IJmuiden, where the fishing fleet lands and the harbour has fish shops and simple eateries. The town is about forty minutes by bus from Haarlem and makes an easy half-day with the beach at IJmuiden aan Zee. Further north, Den Helder is the departure point for Texel ferries and has harbour-side fish shops that sell herring alongside kibbeling and smoked eel. If I were choosing one spot for a first herring and a pleasant morning, I would book a base in Haarlem and take the Saturday market, which is calmer than the Amsterdam stands and easy to combine with the Teylers Museum.
Timing, Etiquette and What to Skip
Go early in the day. Herring stalls open around ten or eleven in the morning and the fish is at its best fresh from the morning's delivery; by late afternoon on a warm day the quality drops. June to September is the window for new-season fish, and the Vlaggetjesdag festival at Scheveningen in June marks the start, though that is just outside Noord-Holland and best treated as a day trip if you are curious. Weekdays are quieter at the Amsterdam stands than weekends, when the queues at Albert Cuyp can stretch.
Order at the counter, pay by card at most stalls, and eat standing. Do not ask for the fish cooked or for mayonnaise on a plain herring; that is a different dish. Skip the pre-made herring salads and jars in supermarkets if you want the real experience, and skip the tourist-facing stands on Damrak, which charge more for a smaller fish than the neighbourhood stalls. A whole herring is a strong flavour for some palates, so a broodje is the sensible first order; if you dislike it, kibbeling, the battered cod bites, is the reliable fallback.
Building a Hotel Stay Around It
Because herring is a street food, you want a hotel near a market square or a station rather than a resort. In Amsterdam, the Haarlemmerbuurt and the streets around the Westerkerk put you within walking distance of the Spui and the Jordaan's cafés, and the Centraal station area gives fast trains to Haarlem and Alkmaar. In Haarlem, the area between the station and the Grote Markt is the practical choice; the walk is around ten minutes and the Saturday market is on your doorstep. Alkmaar's centre around the Waag is small enough that anywhere inside the old moat works.
Book well ahead for June through August, when Amsterdam hotel rates are at their highest and Haarlem and Alkmaar fill with weekend visitors. The same trip in late September still catches the tail of the herring season with lower room rates and thinner crowds. A car is not needed: the rail line from Amsterdam Centraal to Alkmaar and Den Helder runs frequently, and Haarlem is a short hop from Amsterdam Sloterdijk. Nominate Haarlem as a base if you want one or two herring stops with a calmer evening, and Amsterdam if the stalls are one part of a fuller city break.
Related articles
Questions answered
Is it safe to eat raw herring in the Netherlands?
Yes. Dutch herring is gutted, salted and frozen before sale, which removes the parasite risk that applies to truly raw fish. It is not cooked, but the curing and freezing process makes it safe to eat. Buy from a busy stall where turnover is high.
What does herring taste like?
Rich, soft and quite salty, with an oily finish. The texture is closer to sushi than to pickled fish. Onion and sour pickle cut through the fat. If you find strong fish flavours difficult, order a broodje haring rather than a whole fish.
When is herring season in Noord-Holland?
The Hollandse Nieuwe season starts in early June and runs to the end of September. Outside those months, stalls sell herring from the previous catch, which is firmer and saltier. Late September is a good compromise for good fish and lower hotel rates.
How much does a herring cost?
Street stalls sell a broodje haring for a few euros, and a whole herring with onions is usually slightly less. Prices at the tourist-heavy stands on Damrak run higher than at neighbourhood markets such as Albert Cuyp or Haarlem's Grote Markt.
Do I need to speak Dutch to order?
No. Say 'broodje haring' for a roll or 'haring met uitjes' for a whole fish with onions, and you will be understood. Most stallholders in Amsterdam, Haarlem and Alkmaar speak English, and card payment is widely accepted.
Where can I eat herring near Amsterdam Centraal?
The stands on the Spui and around the Albert Cuypmarkt in De Pijp are the easiest from the centre, each a short walk or tram ride from Centraal. For a calmer setting, take the twenty-minute train to Haarlem and visit the Saturday market on the Grote Markt.
Can I combine herring with a beach day?
Yes. IJmuiden, about forty minutes by bus from Haarlem, has harbour fish shops and the beach at IJmuiden aan Zee. Zandvoort is another option on the same rail line from Haarlem, with stalls in summer and a wide sandy beach.
Which is better as a base, Amsterdam or Haarlem?
Amsterdam suits a full city break with markets as one stop, though rooms cost more in summer. Haarlem is calmer, cheaper and still within twenty minutes of Amsterdam by train, with its own Saturday market and easy access to IJmuiden and Alkmaar.
Every stay booked through Stay Noord-Holland funds one verified tonne of carbon removal — same room, same price, the climate action already built into checkout.
You're not charged more and the hotel isn't paid less. It's just what happens when you tap Reserve.